Why do Agencies Concentrate so Much on Trying to be Different?

iveIn my role as advisor to both brands on how to find agencies and agencies on how to find new clients, one thing has been nagging at me for a while now. Why is it that so many agencies spend so long trying to make themselves appear unique?

Think about it for a minute. If you’re a marketing director with £5m to spend are you really looking for a totally unique ageny to give it too? I doubt it very much.

Clients are not looking for an agency that is completely different from the one they already have – they just want one that is BETTER than the one they already have.

So, when sitting down to write your agency proposition, stop trying so hard to make it different and concentrate on what it is about you that by its very nature proovesw that you are BETTER than the competition, not simply different from them.

Posted in Just thoughts | Tagged , | Leave a comment

A Lesson For Us All

I have been having enormous problems with the service provided by one of our partners. The firm I really like, been using them for years. Know the directors well and really respect them. But the service went dramatically down hill after we had moved office due to our new location. It got so bad that I had no alternative but to find a new solution.

So I signed up with a new service provider who offered an alternative solution to the one provided by our existing partner.

I then told our existing supplier who only THEN told me that they could provide that solution as well! So lessons learned for me.

  1. Ask your existing partner if they have an alternative solution before switching suppliers if you are happy with them but not the service.

Lessons for my parter.

  1. Make sure your clients are aware of your full service offering
  2. If a service isn’t working, don’t keep on trying desperately to make it work, offer an alternative if you have one.

 

Posted in Just thoughts | Leave a comment

Leo Burnett – Advertising Legend

This doesn’t really need any further clarification. A great man.

Posted in Funny or cool, Just thoughts | Leave a comment

How to Choose a New Business Agency

We’ve been around longer than most new business agencies or indeed prospective clients, so I think it is fair to say that when it comes to the problem of how to select a new business agency we’ve seen the good, the bad and the plain ugly!

So here we go – here’s our view on how best to go about it.

1 – Google “new business agency” – discount anyone not on the front page, you want someone who’s good at marketing themselves and if they can’t even figure out SEO then there’s no help for them. It’s not like there are thousands of us out there!

2 – Make a list of the hygiene factors you NEED. Is location important, do you want someone who works with other agencies like you or do you consider that a conflict.

3 – Choose an initial list of five, call them and speak to the MD, tell him or her about what you are looking for and take ten minutes or so to get a feel for them and what they are like.

4 – Whittle the list down to three and invite them in to take a thorough brief from you so that they can submit a proposal. Don’t ask them to bring the team they’d have working on your business in at this stage. If they already know then they’re choosing the team based upon who is available and not who would best fit the brief.

5 – Once you’ve seen the proposals, you’ll probably have already discounted one, have one favourite and one close second, so the nest step is to visit those latter two at their offices to meet the prospective team. Ask to meet them without the MD, see what happens. This will indicate the amount of trust the MD has in his or her team! Don’t grill them, just get a feel for them – would you be happy having them represent your brand.

6 – Take out a credit check on them – you want a partner that is financially stable.

7 – Ask to see their entire client list and then choose three clients at random and ask them if you can speak with those clients.

8 – Make your decision.

 

Posted in Blogroll, Just thoughts, Resources | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Puzzle or Mystery? Agency New Business, a Paradigm Shift

Whilst on holiday I read Malcolm Gladwell’s new book, “What the Dog Saw”, a collection of his writing from The Spectator. One of the many insightful essays was on the vagaries of the stock market and hedge funds and how too much information can be a bad thing. His hypothesis was that in the pre internet age, trying to anticipate market movements was a puzzle. One had to search for the right piece of information and once found it was added to what you had already found until the picture was complete. Very neat and tidy.

With the advent and exponential growth of the internet, however, we are surrounded by all the information we need. Search Google for instance, for “will facebook shares rise in value” and you will find (as of 9.30am GMT, 7th August 2012) 93,900,000 hits. So this is no longer a puzzle. It is a mystery; we are surrounded by so much information our role is not to search, but to be intuitive and know what is useful and what is not.

The same is, of course, true for agency new business. Taking a single source of information and hoping it will provide the answer to the puzzle (is the client happy with their agency or not?) is, at best naive. Surround yourself with as much information as you can about the company and think, deeply and intuitively.

Posted in Just thoughts, Resources | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

How to Minimise Road Rage?

I have an old Volvo XC90, the horn is VERY loud and you can’t really “pip pip” it as you have to really press down on the steering wheel to make it go “BEEEEEPPP!!!!“.

My wife has a little Fiat 500. The horn is very sweet and almost apologetically “peeps”.

I was in my Volvo the other day and was sat behind someone at some traffic lights. He was obviously searching for something and hadn’t noticed that the lights had changed, so, after about ten seconds, I gave him what I wanted to be a little “pip pip” to wake him up. Not a big deal, we’ve all missed the change and when I do it, as long as the person behind isn’t aggressive, I don’t mind and wave to apologise.

Sadly my Volvo doesn’t go “pip pip” it went ”BEEEEEPPP!!!!“. The other person was OK, but I was rather embarrassed and it COULD have caused a bit of road rage if the other person was of that disposition.

So, here’s my point. Why don’t car manufacturers install two horns. One that goes ”BEEEEEPPP!!!!” for emergency situations and another that goes ”pip pip” for less urgent ones, one’s where you just need to make someone aware of a non-critical situation.

Posted in Just thoughts | Leave a comment

Pitch Specialisation, Show Integration for Agency New Business

I was running an advertising pitch for a large University a year or so back and the brief was very specific – they wanted an advertising agency to run an advertising campaign. The pitches were taking place at RSW’s office over one day. At the end of the day I had a de-briefing with the marketing director who was the client making the decision.

She said that although one of the agencies had really grabbed her attention, she would find it very difficult to use them because they had pitched themselves as an integrated agency and had provided an integrated solution; I said, “well, what’s wrong with that! surely that’s a good solution!”. She went on to explain …

She had been tasked with finding an ADVERTISING agency. There were other people within the organisation who were responsible for the other disciplines; there was an online marketing manager, a DM manager and a PR manager. All these people had their own agencies and were very protective. If she chose the integrated agency, it would cause just too many political problems for her. So she discounted them. Shame really.

So. What COULD that agency have done? Her’s my view.

When asked to answer an advertising brief, pitch an advertising solution that would take up the budget you have been told to work to. Then, show them examples of how that big idea could work across other disciplines “if you decided to get your other agencies to follow our suggestions, or indeed, were to ask us to take the idea further”.

This way you are not encroaching onto any areas you have not been asked to explore but are showing your integrated thinking.

Posted in Just thoughts, New Business Stories | Leave a comment

If anything goes wrong … (in agency new business)

The great Bear Bryant once famous said …

“If anything goes wrong, I did it. If anything goes semi-good, then we did it. If anything goes real good, then you did it. That’s all it takes to win football games.”

It is a quote I like so much that I have it on the back of my business cards (at RSW, everyone gets to choose a quote that inspires them for the back of their cards), but what does it mean in practice?

Well for one thing, we need to accept that when we ask someone to do something, we need to be absolutely sure of all of the possible consequences and, if any of those consequences are unpleasant or unpalatable accept that if they happen, then it is YOUR fault.

Next, if you ask someone to do something and they do it and the consequences are fabulous, then hey, have the humility to allow them to take the credit.

Maslow taught us that  self-actualization is at the top of the hierarchy of needs and it is our jobs as managers of people to help them achieve this state and what better way than by protecting them from criticism whilst allowing them to take all the credit. It is the philosophy not only Bear, but of all of the great team managers.

Posted in Just thoughts | Tagged | Leave a comment

Four Cornerstones of Sales for Agency New Business

In agency new business, like any sales operation, we need to effectively measure the performance of our teams. To do this effectively, it is always worth remembering the four cornerstones upon which effective sales are built. They are, of course:

1) ABILITY - The person undertaking the activity must have the raw ability to perform the task. Some people are inherently timid when it comes to picking up the telephone and cold calling a senior decision maker. They fee inferior or maybe a little ashamed. These people do not have the wherewithal you need and should not be employed in the first place.

2) KNOWLEDGE - Once you have a team with the right ability, you need to imbibe them with the product knowledge and knowledge of how to actually ‘make a sale’; teach them DIPADA or AIDA or SPIN if you like, but more importantly, provide them with the knowledge that will enable them to discuss marketing problems with the people you want to work with.

3) ATTITUDE - Now you have the right people (or person) and they have the right product knowledge and have been trained in how to make the sale, the next step is to make sure they have the right attitude; this is where most teams fall over because keeping a buzz going is an agency new business team can be difficult, especially if the team is a team of one poor soul left alone in a room with a telephone and a computer and expected to deliver the results!

4) ACTIVITIES - Now this is the really interesting one. What do we mean by this? why, those things many sales people HATE to be measured by. Tasks completed. How many dials are being made per day? How many Decision Maker Contacts (DMC’s or Effectives) are made and how many sales (or meetings) are arranged. These should be measured and compared on a daily, weekly and monthly basis and tweaked.

So, let’s take a scenario. You have a great person, they’ve been trained properly. They start well enough but it then starts to trail off. Their head’s down, the call rates down and guess what? meetings booked or sales made are down too. Where are the problems here? Well 1 and 2 are fine, so its 3 and 4 where the problem lies. Which do you tackle first? Attitude or Activities? I would say Activities. If you know that for each 100 dials you will make 10 DMC’s and arrange 1 meeting and your new business person is making 20 dials per day (because they’re SO busy “researching”), they will make 1 meeting per week. What if you want 2 or 3 meetings per week? Hey, as they say in the States “you do the math!”. That’s right, get them to make 50 dials per day. Or increase their Access rate of course (if their knowledge could be improved).

Once you have tackled the ACTIVITIES you usually find that they start to improve their own ATTITUDE because they’re back on a roll.

But be careful how you tackle this issue. You cannot simply demand more output. You need to carefully manage the situation or ATTITUDE will worsen and you’ll lose your highly trained talent and have to start all over again.

Which is why, of course, many agencies decide the whole role should be outsourced, NOT THE WHOLE OF BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT of course, just the UPSTREAM ELEMENT. Sales people are like wolves. They hunt better in packs.

Posted in Just thoughts, Resources | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Sort Out Your Website for Agency New Business

Why is it that so many agency websites are as bad as they are? I’m not saying they’re all bad and I’m not saying that our own is perfect, but some are really, VERY poor indeed, with almost as many still ‘under construction’ due to being ‘so busy with client business’ or some other feeble excuse.

When will these agencies get it? Do they honestly not think it important? Do they believe (as many have told me) that the less they show the better because that way clients will have to ask them in to find out more? In the words of my ten year-old …

Really? No, REALLY??

Ponder the following scenarios.

1) Client has agreed to meet with a new agency to find out more about them. The client is considering reviewing the incumbent but has not let on yet because she wants to meet with half a dozen or so before deciding whether to definitely review and if so then who to include in the process. Now, what would YOU do, if you were HER, fifteen minutes before the meeting is due to commence? I know what I do when checking out potential new suppliers. I go to their website to remind myself of why I agreed to meet them and to see if there is anything there that I will need further clarification on. She finds a landing page. Not a good start really is it?

2) Client (or Intermediary) has met with various agencies and now want to whittle that list of six down to three to pitch. To refresh their memories they go to the agency website – ditto. holding page. What do you expect them to do? Call you up and ask you to re-send over some more case studies? It won’t happen …

3) Client is unhappy with their incumbent, they do their desk research, look through Campaign Top 300 list, ask their peers and then pull together a list of twelve agencies to do some due diligence on before inviting six in for chemistry meetings before deciding which three to invite to pitch. Your agency is one of the twelve. She goes to your website and finds that same holding page. Do you think she will give you the benefit of the doubt or do you think she will now choose her six from the eleven who have made her life easier?

So, if you have a holding page. Take it down – replace it with a blog if necessary. Just get some content online.

If you have a website, take a look at those of your competitors and ask yourself whether you come up to scratch. If the answer is no, do something about it. The agency website is now first port of call for most reviews; if you fail here, you make life very hard for yourself.

Posted in Just thoughts, Rant | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment